I consistently switch off my phone as I step into a cinema. Not just on silent mode – all the way off. I mention this not from a place of judgment, or to suggest that the ghost of a classic director will appear to offer approval. I view it as a simple minor indulgences: for at least an hour and a half, I am completely disconnected. I maintain my phone off during the scroll as well. It strikes me as luxurious to stay put as fellow attendees slowly filter out, bathed in the light of the scrolling names.
And, more and more, by the glow of the cataloguing app.
Over 26 million users utilize Letterboxd, a movie-logging platform. In the vein of A24, it has become industry shorthand for a certain breed of tastemaker who hypes new releases and delights in unearthing old classics. Patrons score and write about films, and the funniest or most articulate commentaries ascend to the top, incentivizing movie buffs to write diligently.
"If I don't get my thoughts out quickly after the credits roll, my critiques are far less lucid and well-put," said one user.
On a recent outing to the cinema, the credits had barely started before the patron in the row ahead started composing his review. A few seats over, a pair lingered, heads bowed, noting their personal reactions.
The legendary director David Lynch once offered advice: note every great idea the exact moment it comes to mind. Failing to do so, it could be forgotten, and, in his words: "Losing a valuable thought, you want to commit suicide." Lynch was addressing budding directors, a similar ethos applies to the Letterboxd experience.
Josh Stern, a young university attendee in New York, always composes his assessments before leaving the auditorium.
"If I don't jot down my ideas quickly after the credits roll, my critiques are much less clear and eloquent," he explained. "It takes a bit. I'm pretty slow, and my partner doesn't like it."
He goes to the movies frequently – 182 times last year – and is on a familiar terms with the ushers, who sometimes have to ask him to leave so they can commence sweeping the theater. He believes it acceptable to take advantage of the credit sequence: "Upon buying a theater ticket, the closing sequence are part of the feature."
Letterboxd's most passionate users credit the platform with reinvigorating excitement around a challenged movie business, where output has decreased and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also has the type of audience data advertisers covet – its largest cohort of users is between 18 and 24, then 25 to 35.)
Buzz creates more hype; much-hyped movies see a surge of reviews on Letterboxd shortly following the initial screenings. The most-liked critique of a divisive adaptation – "the author died long ago yet this interpretation is still the most egregious event that has ever affected her" – has amassed over 50,000 double-taps. A separate fictionalized retelling produced this contrast to a major artist's concert film: "that other tour film found dead."
"It feels like a habit," remarked a marketing professional, a 33-year-old resident who has a career in marketing. He also likes to write reviews in the credits. "Reflecting on what you just experienced, right after you saw it, aids the viewing experience. It clarifies the key messages of a film. If it produces a feeling of a warm hug, that's not always something you retain the next day."
He feels most motivated to review a film if it was very good – or exceptionally bad. Case in point: he recently endured a big-budget vehicle. "I found myself so disappointed by how utterly terrible it was, that I was excited to whip out my phone and assign it a half-star review," he said. (He is a tougher reviewer than other professional critics, who gave the film a more favorable review, labeling it "clever and engaging material.")
Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old New Yorker who is in social media, watched a fantasy feature at a local theater and remained to draft the write-up ("I gave it a perfect score"). He has clocked poorer etiquette: people whipping out their phones to review the movie they are actively viewing. "That action annoys me," he commented.
One of the movie industry's most enduring tales tells of a exhibition of an 1896 silent short that featured a train pulling into a station. The medium was in its earliest days and – according to this debunked story – the shot of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera shocked the audience so much that people ran away in panic.
Many decades later, cinema etiquette remains just as problematic. It seems, no one knows how to behave in a theater these days, especially when the theater darkens: patrons take pictures of the image, bring in smelly food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, at times get into outright brawls.
A number of users have turned to social media to discuss the propriety of writing reviews during the credits. When one social media user